Ball valve or butterfly valve?
Updated:
Ball and butterfly valves are the most common quarter-turn (90°) valves in industrial plants. Both open and close with a quarter turn of a lever or gearbox, but their internal design makes them suited to different jobs.
How does a ball valve work?
Inside the body sits a ball with a bore through its centre. When the bore lines up with the flow the valve is open; turned 90° it is closed. In full-bore models the bore equals the pipe diameter, so pressure loss is very low.
- Excellent sealing; often preferred on gas and fuel lines.
- Wide range available in high pressure ratings (PN40, Class 300 and above).
- Nothing obstructs the flow path when open (full-bore models suit cleaning or pigging).
- In large sizes the body gets heavy and costs more than a butterfly valve.
- Not suited to throttling; running half-open wears the seat.
How does a butterfly valve work?
A disc rotates on a shaft across the pipe bore. Parallel to the flow the valve is open, perpendicular it is closed. Because the disc stays in the flow even when open, pressure loss is higher than with a ball valve.
- Short face-to-face length and low weight make it economical and easy to fit in large sizes (DN100 and up).
- Available as wafer, lug and flanged bodies; the wafer type, clamped between two flanges, is the most common.
- Common on water, cooling water and HVAC lines; usable for light throttling.
- Soft (elastomer) seats are for low and medium pressure; high temperature and pressure call for double- or triple-offset metal-seated “high performance” butterfly valves.
Which one should I choose?
| Criterion | Ball valve | Butterfly valve |
|---|---|---|
| Small size (≤ DN50) | Usually preferred | Rarely |
| Large size (≥ DN150) | Can be heavy and costly | Usually preferred |
| High pressure | Suitable | High performance types only |
| Pressure loss | Very low (full bore) | Higher, disc stays in the flow |
| Sealing | Very good | Good (depends on the seat material) |
| Throttling | Not recommended | Possible to a limited extent |
| Space and weight | More | Less |
In short: ball valves usually make sense in small and medium sizes, at high pressure, or on gas and fuel lines that need tight shut-off; butterfly valves usually make sense on large-diameter water and HVAC lines. The fluid, temperature and pressure decide the final choice. If you are unsure, send us your requirements and we will work it out together.
